|
On Fri, 16 May 2025
at 22:02, Paul Borisoff wrote:
Ilya, I'm
wondering if there's any way to get more information on
one or both of these sisters. The Fanny you mentioned
was buried in South America. Again at this point I
don't know whether any of grandmother's family got out
of Odessa?
Ilya wrote: Paul,
Let me answer your questions by asking more questions...
The document with the
dates of birth of all Drobatchewsky family members including all
the sisters, that I sent you earlier, is a part of 1874 town of
Novomirgorod census of Jews...
Q: Does it mean that all
the families listed in that document lived in Novomirgorod?
A: Not at all! Because
in Russian Empire all Jews had to be registered at some place.
This registration system was introduced in early 19th century
(together with introduction of the family n ames for Jews).
Registration was 1. expensive to change and 2) it did not stop
from moving. That's why by the end of 19th century many families
actually lived at one place but were still registered on the
other (old) place. Registration, basically, defined the place
where to pay taxes and where the male family member could be
drafted you into the army.
Q: OK, in 1874 family
was registered in Novomirgorod. But where did it actually live?
A. Yes, we are lucky, because this list also does tell that. It
is written there that the family does live actually in Zlatopol.
Q. Wow, cool! But
where's Zlatopol, how far it is from Novomirgorod?
A.. Actually Zlatopol
was just across the river:

Click image above to enlarge.
Nowadays Zlatopol does
not exist as a separate town anymore, it was merged with
Novomirgorod. I think it happened sometimes in the middle of XX
century.
Q. What's the point then
to move... just across the river.
A. We don't know
exactly, but I would guess that... it was the opposite, the
family lived in Zlatopol from the beginning, but changed it's
registration from Zlatopol to Novomirgorod's one. I have heard
that it was very typical for that place. The reason was that
although two neighboring towns were just separated with the
river, they also belonged to different provinces.
Zlotopol belonged to Kiev province, and Novomirgorod belonged to
the Kherson's province. After 1917
provinces were renamed and changed. You can see it at the left
top corner of the fragment of the map above... the border
between provinces was moved north-west, and Novomirgorod and
Zlatopol are now the same province.
Q. Why did they change
registration in this peculiar way?
A. We can only guess... Perhaps the officials
in the Kherson province were kinder, or perhaps the taxes there
were lower, or perhaps something else.
Q. Alright, clear. But, next
question, if this is the census of 1874, how does Maryam, who
was born in 1896, end up on this list?...
and all her other sisters and her brother Genich / Heinrich?
A. This is because there
were no more censuses until 1898. Well, there was a special
census of 1875 taken for potential army conscription. And most
of the data of 1898 census did not survived. The
1898 census was used to compile
statistical data on the population of the Empire and then the
raw data had to be destroyed as was originally planed. So
only in some places 1898 data survived, and then only in
fragments. Basically we are lucky with this 1874 list as
the additions like this were not common. Perhaps, it was a
Novomirgorod initiative.
Now there is new
information to consider:
The
registers of births, deaths, marriages and divorces in Odessa
for the years 1875-1920 are quite well preserved and are now
available online at this
link... (Occasionally other dates are indicated
there, but in fact the data for 1875-1920 has been mostly
preserved). For ease of use, there are even alphabetical lists,
which already indicate the location of a particular record in
the original registers. All are in the Russian language.
The
members of the Drobаchevskу family known to us (Genich /
Khaya-Rokhl / Fenya / Reisa / Maryam) are absent from these
books! That means that they were not born in Odessa...
Q. Alright, but where
were they born?
A. We do not know.
Highly likely in Zlatopol, but there is no proof yet.
What else is known from
this 1874 census? There are the documents
confirming that the information in the census is listed... this
includes the marriage certificate of Solomon Drobachevsky and
Sonya, number 321, dated February 19, 1888.
Q. Is the marriage
certificate shown there?
A. No, only it's
number and the date.
Q. What can we use this information for?
A. Well, it
tells us that Genich/Heinrich was the first child in the
family. The parents married on February 19, 1888.
Genich was born on January 25, 1889. And, as
Solomon Drobatchewsky got married on February 19, 1888
and was born in 1867. We can calculate that his
age was 21 when he was married and its highly likely
that it was his first marriage. We don't know his wife
Sonja's date of birth. (Usually if the
groom got married at the age of 21, the bride was one to
three years younger than him. Before 21 years of
age, men usually did not take older girls as wives.
At the end of the 19th century men were not married off
until they were 17.
But those calculations give us very important fact...
when Maryam was born in 1896, her mother was ~28 years
old. What stopped Solomon Drobatchewsky and Sonja
produce more children? We know that both parents lived
to upper middle or even into old age. Technically
something medical could have happened to prevent them
from having more children... but does this apply to
them? You know, I recently saw in some database that a
Tatiana Drobatchewasky was born around 1907 who was the
daughter of Solomon. First, I ignored that record
because it was before I made the simple calculation of
the various ages... but now I'm trying to find that
record again and I can't locate it. Hopefully I will
find it again soon. But basically, I would say it
is open question... were there more siblings.
When did
Drobatchewsky family moved to Odessa? In the book you
have sent me it is said that Henry's father (Solomon)
played trumpet in the Odessa opera (page 12, last
paragraph). It could be very well that Solomon lived in
Odessa playing trumpet and Sonja stayed in Zlatopol with
the children (and it necessarily had nothing to do with
possible family problems... no, it was very often
practice among the poor families that a husband moved to
another city for earnings and the rest of the family
stayed the original place for many years. This may
also be the reason that there were no additional
children in the family, by the way).
Q. OK, but the
birth records books of Odessa do exist. Are their any
records of more Drobatchewsky children after 1896?
A. No, there
aren't. There's one or or two records on other
Drobatchewskys, related to Solomon, but there are no
records showing more Solomon children.
Q. The death
record of Khaya-Rokhl is from Odessa (1919)?
A. Yes, this
record is from Odessa.
Q. OK, there are birth, death, marriage records from
Odessa. Are there perhaps records of marriages of
Fenya and/or Reisa?
A. Perhaps. I
don't know. And the reason for that is that Odessa was a
very large city. Half a million of people lived there at
the beginning of XX century. 1/3 of them were Jewish.
The birth, death, marriage records books are really
thick, and being all handwritten it is an enormous task
to read them all.
Q. But you said
there's alphabets lists making it easy to find a person?
A. Yes, but marriage listings are for males only. It is
very easy to find a groom in the alphabets lists, but
there are no lists for brides, save for only one or two
years. And I have already checked them.
Q. OK, clear.
But what's about Fanny Drobatchewsky who was buried in
South America?
|
|